Andi Dorfman cheated with Josh’s brother Aaron Murray?

Normally I would write this sort of claim off because it sounds so bizarre and so unlike Bachelorette Andi Dorfman, but the statement by Aaron’s fiance’s grandmother makes me think this has to be true.

Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Aaron Murray, 24 proposed to his girlfriend Channel 41 reporter Kacie McDonnell on October 11th, but they broke up shortly after in January.

“[Aaron] knows what he did and he has to live with it,” Kacie’s grandmother told Radar Online. “When it happened, we came together as a family.”

In fact their break up was days after Andi Dorfman and Josh Murray announced their split.

And there may have been a reason for that. 28-year-old Georgia attorney Andi Dorfman allegedly hooked up with Josh’s brother Aaron Murray, while both couples were still engaged!

Kacie has since moved on with Kansas City Royals player Eric Hosmer, but apparently the damage has been done.

As a side note I believe that it was Kacie who got Josh on the show! Why do I think that? Because I recall reading that it was a “family member in Philadelphia” who submitted Josh for the show and it does not appear that the Murray clan has any close family in Philly, but brother Aaron had a longtime girlfriend who was a news reporter in Philly aka she had a lot of Television connections.

Josh was rumored to be the next Bachelor, but it sounds like ABC has officially chosen Ben Higgins over Josh. No word on whether or not this event contributed to the decision.